Skip to content
16 November 2026

Is a new curse haunting EA Sports’ College Football 27?

Dante Moore, Malachi Toney and Kewan Lacy, the faces of College Football 27, are all out for the season, fueling talk of a college‑football version of the Madden curse.

Is a new curse haunting EA Sports’ College Football 27?

EA Sports released College Football 27 with Oregon quarterback Dante Moore, Miami running back Malachi Toney and Oklahoma State wide receiver Kewan Lacy on its cover. All three entered the 2026 campaign as Heisman Trophy frontrunners for teams with legitimate championship aspirations. Within weeks, each athlete suffered a serious injury that forced him to miss the remainder of the regular season, reigniting the long-standing superstition known as the “Madden curse“.

Injuries that removed the cover stars

Moore’s troubles began in Week 4 when a high-impact collision with Southern California resulted in a violent concussion. The hit sent the quarterback to a hospital for observation, and although scans showed no lasting brain damage, Oregon’s coaching staff opted for a cautious approach. On October 26, head coach Dan Lanning announced that Moore would not return for the rest of the year, limiting his contribution to just four games.

Toney’s situation unfolded on November 4, just before Miami faced Notre Dame. The running back suffered a severe lower-leg injury that required a medical procedure, sidelining him indefinitely. Team physicians projected an “extended period of time” out of action, effectively ending his regular-season participation and leaving his playoff eligibility uncertain.

Lacy’s misfortune was reported on November 12. After missing two consecutive matches with a lingering shoulder problem, the wide receiver was confirmed to have a left-shoulder injury that would keep him off the field for the balance of the season. He appeared in only six games before the injury forced his exit.

The “Madden curse” and its legacy

The term “Madden curse” describes the belief that appearing on the cover of EA’s flagship NFL franchise brings bad luck to the featured player during the following season. The phenomenon dates back to Madden 99, when San Francisco 49ers running back Garrison Hearst suffered a devastating ankle injury shortly after his cover debut. Subsequent cover athletes—including Marshall Faulk (Madden 03), Michael Vick (Madden 04), Donovan McNabb (Madden 06), Peyton Hillis (Madden 12) and Christian McCaffrey (Madden 25)—experienced injuries or dramatic performance declines.

Not every cover star has been cursed; Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes have both enjoyed successful seasons after their appearances. Nevertheless, the pattern has persisted enough to become a cultural talking point among fans and analysts, who often scour the headlines for any hint of misfortune after a new cover is announced.

Potential pattern emerging in college football?

College football has historically escaped the curse’s grip. Travis Hunter graced the cover of College Football 25 and went on to win the Heisman Trophy, while Ryan Coleman-Williams and Jeremiah Smith appeared on College Football 26 and helped their teams reach the College Football Playoff. The recent trio of injuries, however, suggests that the superstition may be extending into the collegiate realm.

With three high-profile athletes, each a contender for the sport’s most prestigious individual award, removed from play in a single season, speculation is growing that a new “college-football curse” could be forming. While the sample size remains small, the coincidence echoes the original Madden narrative and fuels endless debate on whether the phenomenon is psychological, purely random, or a blend of both. As the season progresses, observers will watch closely to see if any future cover athletes manage to avoid a similar fate.

Author

Maya Kline

Maya Kline writes about The Games, delivering news, reviews, and analysis tailored for GamelandMag readers. She covers gameplay trends, developer insights, platform comparisons, and buying guidance, translating industry developments into clear, practical coverage for players.